Carmen asked:

If God really exists why do bad things happen to good people?

============

I certainly don't know, but here is one answer that has been given, on the supposition that God exists,
of course:

It is that certain bad things that happen, what are often called evils, are necessaryevils. That means
that without these evils certain goodthings could not exist, and that these good things are worth
these evils so that it is better for these good things to exist even if the evil things also exist, than for
the good things (and of course the evil things) not to exist.

You know how sometimes you are willing to accept a necessary evil because you believe that only
that way can you have a good thing whose goodness is worth the bad thing? For instance, suppose
your dentist tells you that you need a root canal procedure. Not a pleasant thing. But you have it done
anyway because unless you do you will have greater trouble. So you have this unpleasant procedure
for the sake of a healthy mouth. You accept an evil because it is a necessary evil. Now, let's apply
this to your question. We all believe (I think) that compassion for people in trouble or in need is a
good thing, don't we? On the other hand, isn't it true that for there to be compassion, there have to be
people in trouble, perhaps very ill? You could not be compassionate about nothing! So, according to
this answer, certain kinds of evils exist for the sake of the compassion which is good.

Now there are problems with this answer. But maybe you just want to think about it before you think
about any difficulties with it.

Ken Stern