Are all genuine problems scientific? what is left for philosophers to do in a post modern age?
============
A counter-question: are ANY genuine problems scientific? Once astrophysicists have nailed down the
Higgs Field, what's left for them to talk about? — Let me give you a hint you might like to ponder. At
this moment, a war is being fought in Iraq. Many people throughout the world disagree with the
decision of the US government to wage this war. Is this a problem? Surely it is! But what's it got to do
with science?
Jürgen Lawrenz
Sydney
Well, your first question itself raises a genuine a problem which does not appear to be scientific. It's
clearly not physics or chemistry or anything like that, is it?
It seems likely that only a philosophical answer could deliver a satisfactory response your question. It
therefore answers itself to an extent.
It is a point that is often missed that when people say things like "the only important truths are
scientific truths" they are not making a scientific statement but a philosophical one.
Such statements are sometimes said to be "pragmatically inconsistent" — i.e their assertion is
inconsistent with their being true.